top of page

The Guilty-Plea Decision

The criminal justice system is built upon the foundational principle that every defendant has the right to a fair trial. However, in many cases, defendants choose to plead guilty instead of exercising this right. While pleading guilty is not a constitutional right, it is sometimes in a defendant's best interest. In this article, we will explore the delicate balance between the right to a trial and the strategic considerations that may lead a defendant to plead guilty, with or without a plea deal.

Many of our clients' cases are dismissed. But if your case is not dismissed before you have to make the choice of pleading guilty or going to trial, what do you do? How do you decide?

The Right to a Trial: The Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution guarantees the right to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury in criminal cases. This fundamental right is essential for protecting freedom, as it allows defendants to present their case, challenge the prosecution's evidence, and hold the government accountable for proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Often the government will not dismiss a case until the eve of trial; pleading guilty before the eve of trial deprives you of the possibility that this will happen.

The Reality of Pleading Guilty: Despite the importance of the right to a trial, the majority of criminal cases are resolved through guilty pleas. Defendants may choose to plead guilty for various reasons, including avoiding the time, expense, and uncertainty of a trial, as well as the potential for a more favorable outcome through a plea deal.

Rights and Best Interests: As defense attorneys, our primary responsibility is to advocate for our client and protect his or her interests. This includes advising clients on whether to exercise their right to a trial or consider pleading guilty. In doing so, we consider several factors:

  1. Strength of the Prosecution's Case: We analyze the evidence against our clients and assess the likelihood of a conviction at trial. If the prosecution's case is strong, pleading guilty may minimize the risk of a harsher sentence.

  2. Potential Plea Deals: We negotiate with the prosecution to secure plea agreements that may offer reduced charges or lighter sentences in exchange for a guilty plea. These deals can provide more certainty and a better outcome than risking a trial.

  3. Personal Circumstances: We consider our clients' personal situations, such as their criminal history, family responsibilities, and employment prospects, when advising them on whether to plead guilty or go to trial.

  4. Emotional and Psychological Factors: Going to trial can be a stressful and emotionally draining experience. We help clients weigh the potential psychological toll of a trial against the benefits of a plea deal or an acquittal.


While every defendant has the right to a jury trial, sometimes pleading guilty is in their best interest. As defense attorneys, we are committed to helping our clients navigate this complex decision-making process by providing informed advice and steadfast support. Ultimately, our goal is to ensure our clients achieve the best possible outcome, whether that involves exercising their right to a trial or strategically choosing to plead guilty.

bottom of page